Tags: witness | fake | eye | pops out

Witness's Fake Eye Pops Out in Court, Causing Mistrial

By    |   Thursday, 07 Feb 2013 04:55 PM

Something unexpected happened in a Philadelphia courtroom on Wednesday: A man's eye popped out of his head while he was testifying in an aggravated assault trial.

Jurors gasped when John "Big Red" Huttick caught his glass eye in his hand. Then as he sat weeping with the prosthesis in his palm, everyone in the courtroom reeled and wondered what to do, reported the Philadelphia Inquirer.

Not defense attorney Eileen Hurley. She immediately demanded a mistrial, which the judge granted.

"It was shocking and unexpected. He caught it in his hand and sort of held it there," Hurley told the Inquirer. "Something as disruptive as that is a bell that could not be unrung. It could cause the jury to have undue sympathy for [Huttick] and undue prejudice to the defendant."

Huttick, 48, was testifying against defendant Matthew Brunelli, 23, charged with aggravated assault during a 2011 altercation and facing 10 to 20 years in prison.

Huttick claimed Brunelli punched him so hard in the face during a late-night brawl at a northwest Philly bar that he had to have his left eye surgically removed.

However, Hurley said two witnesses testified that Brunelli only hit Huttick once, in  self defense, after Huttick put him into a bear hug and kneed him the groin.

The assistant district attorney on the case, Mark Gilson, contended Huttick was trying to break up a fight between Brunelli and two other men, including an off-duty police officer.

The prosecutor said Brunelli likely hit Huttick in the face with a key or another sharp object.

"His left eye was punctured, his retina detached and there was a laceration above his eyebrow," Gilson said. He added that a week-long stay in Philadelphia's Wills Eye Hospital didn't alter the need for Huttick's eye removal.

The new trial date is March 4.

More recent crime stories:

Denver Shooting: Mom, Two Children Dead

Coach, 70, Shoots Teens During Robbery Outside Detroit School

Chicago Violence Claims Honor Student Who Was Inaugural Performer


 



© 2017 Newsmax. All rights reserved.

   
1Like our page
2Share
TheWire
Jurors hearing testimony in an aggravated assault trial in a Philadelphia courtroom gasped when witness John "Big Red" Huttick caught his glass eye in his hand. Then as he sat weeping with the prosthesis in his palm, the defense attorney demanded a mistrial, which the judge granted.
witness,fake,eye,pops out
3171
2013-55-07
Thursday, 07 Feb 2013 04:55 PM
Newsmax Inc.
 

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

NEWSMAX.COM
America's News Page
© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved