Skip to main content
Tags: schools | school | private

Turtel: Fierce Competition In Education Weeds Out Rotten Apples

public or private school building and or environs

(Igor Zakharevich/

By    |   Monday, 17 June 2024 02:12 PM EDT


If government-run public schools are so bad, why do we still have them?

One reason is that local municipal “educrats” and radical-left Democrat apologists for public schools claim that we can’t trust the free market to educate our children.

They claim that private schools only care about "greedy" profits, and would cheat parents and students, take their money, make wild promises, or go out of business.

Look at the trade school scandals a few years ago, they say.

Phony trade schools cheated students and parents with bad teaching and empty promises. This is typical of the free market, they say.

No, it is not typical — rather, it is the opposite.

The few bad apples in any field in the free market are just that — the exceptions.

The free market has a harsh taskmaster called competition.

Fierce competition in an education free market acts the same way it does for any product we buy, whether cars, food, or computers.

Fierce competition forces all competitors to keep improving their product's quality, lowering the cost, and giving better service to their customers, or risk going out of business.

To succeed, a free-market school owner must prove that his school is better than his competitors. All free-market (private) schools have to prove their excellence to skeptical parents — their customers.

If a school does not live up to its claims, parent-consumers are merciless.

Like switching TV channels, parents can and do switch to a better school, for they love their children and want their money's worth.

Yes, there are always a few rotten apples in any field, but competition forces the vast majority of apples in the barrel to be honest and healthy.

Parents are not fools or stupid.

They would quickly see if Johnny can read better or worse in a private school.

We don’t need public school teachers who take four years of meaningless education courses in a so-called teacher college to figure that out.

Like a rising tide, fierce competition would force all educational boats to rise.

Computers get faster, cheaper, and more powerful every year.

Similarly, in a free-market education system, educational quality and innovation would explode, while competition would drive down the cost of tuition.

In a fiercely competitive, education free market, your child would quickly learn the basics in safe, competent, innovative schools, rather than wasting 12 years in violent, drug-infested, chronically-incompetent government-run schools.

Also, what hypocrisy for the rotten orchard of government schools to point their finger at a few bad apples in the "private" sector.

For in these monopoly government-run schools, the situation is completely reversed.

The whole system, the whole government-controlled barrel is rotten, and the education for our kids is abysmal at worst or third rate at best.

In a free-market school system, the bad schools would be the exception. In a government-controlled school system, the good schools are the exception.

Government (public) schools are a never-ending education disaster because they have no accountability to parents.

The schools' teachers, principals, and administrators are civil-service government workers who are paid by their local State or city government, not directly by parents (as is the case with private school owners).

Yes, there are some good, dedicated teachers in public schools, but the system breeds mediocrity on a massive scale, and it's the system that parents have to put up with.

Year after year, compulsory local taxes prop up these schools, no matter how bad they are.

Compulsory school taxes also pay teachers', principals', and administrators' salaries, no matter how bad or mediocre these tenured government employees are.

So, no matter how bad these schools are, or how miserable the education they give our children, parents have no power to make changes in the system.

That is also because every state has compulsory attendance laws that force parents to bring their children to these government-run schools (if they cannot afford a private school), whether they like it or not.

In effect, these schools are government-enforced education prisons, both for parents and their children.

The difference between government and free market schools is this — when government schools are rotten, when they dumb-down our kids with woke indoctrination and nonsense education theories that fail, 50 million public-school children across America can suffer for twelve years, without parents having any recourse.

In contrast, if and when an entrepreneur-owned free market school is bad, only a handful of children suffer for a few months while parents shop for a better school — with parents having full recourse and freedom of choice.

Public-school apologists criticizing private schools for not being accountable to parents is a sick joke, but a joke that is tragic for our children. To education bureaucrats who point to alleged bad apples in the "private" education sector, we can only say — "Doctor, heal thyself."

Joel Turtel is the author of: "Public Schools, Public Menace," "The Welfare State: No Mercy For The Middle Class," and "Patriot Stories."

© 2024 Newsmax. All rights reserved.

Local municipal "educrats" and radical-left Democrat apologists for public schools claim that we can’t trust the free market to educate our children. They claim that private schools only care about "greedy" profits, and would cheat parents and students.
schools, school, private
Monday, 17 June 2024 02:12 PM
Newsmax Media, Inc.

Sign up for Newsmax’s Daily Newsletter

Receive breaking news and original analysis - sent right to your inbox.

(Optional for Local News)
Privacy: We never share your email address.
Join the Newsmax Community
Read and Post Comments
Please review Community Guidelines before posting a comment.

Interest-Based Advertising | Do not sell or share my personal information

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

America's News Page
© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved
Download the NewsmaxTV App
Get the NewsmaxTV App for iOS Get the NewsmaxTV App for Android Scan QR code to get the NewsmaxTV App
America's News Page
© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved