Tags: stocks | market | high | breadth

'Hope Trade' Returns as S&P 500 Reaches Record Highs

'Hope Trade' Returns as S&P 500 Reaches Record Highs
(Stock Photo Secrets/Rob Williams)

By    |   Friday, 15 July 2016 06:15 AM

All it takes are the words “record high” and all economic or financial sins are forgiven and forgotten. The financial media cannot contain themselves whenever they get the chance to use the term, adding qualifications like “soar” and “sharply” to make sure everyone gets the message. Context need not apply because stocks are supposed to be forward-looking discounting mechanisms.

However, even a small bit of background dispels the sentiment.

Fantasy, Meet Reality

Dating back to especially the Federal Reserve's third round of quantitative easing, the stock market had been trading on only the economy that “will be” not the growth environment that actually was.

We know that, given the behavior in prices as they diverged sharply with actual earnings — all on the premise that forward earnings were solid and reasonable based on QE actually working. That was already a somewhat shaky premise in 2013, but by the middle of 2014 it was increasingly negated. Where $140 in EPS for the S&P 500 was expected in calendar 2015, only $86 occurred.

Yet stocks have only traded sideways with increasing volatility; there has yet to be an adjustment to EPS or a more realistic assessment of the global economy apart from that. If 15 times earnings applies to a relatively robust earnings growth environment, what multiple should be assigned to more unsatisfactory growth? Or slow and steady economic contraction? Record highs in the context of this re-evaluation take on an entirely different connotation.

Central Bank Hopium

It starts and ends with stocks still trading on the economy that “will be,” though now downgraded to the economy that hopefully “might be.” Buying interest seems to be at least a taste of what once was, especially in the past few days of resurgent optimism perhaps related to Japan.

It isn’t so much that the Bank of Japan will do whatever it will do, rather it is the fantasy that whatever the BoJ does is the opening round of global central banks finally finding the magic number (or policy format) that unlocks the full “will be” economy.

We know this is nothing but hope because there is no reasonable basis for the expectation; central banks and monetary policies have uniformly failed in such universal, widespread fashion (economy and monetary) as to leave no doubt.

Shaky Highs

Though the S&P 500 this week closed at a new record high, it represents only a one-year gain of 2.5 percent and relative performance far more aligned with this kind of uncertain environment. That is the best view of stocks, as other indices have actually underperformed. Notably, and I think importantly, the S&P 500 Buyback Index is down almost 5 percent in the same one-year period, and down almost 9 percent since its high in February 2015 – all despite the current rally from the lows of February 11.

The broader NYSE Composite also continues to be unfavorably situated, down 2 percent in the one-year period and almost 3 percent since February 24 last year. Worse, for the two-year period through today, the index is also down 2.4 percent, meaning that the broader market has gone nowhere for several years now – all coincident to the appearance of the “rising dollar” that spoiled the hope.

Focusing on the S&P 500 and its new highs is therefore misleading. That is especially true in comparison to “risk-off” assets such as gold or U.S. Treasurys. The longer UST bonds or bond funds are up more than 20 percent in both the one- and two-year periods, while the intermediate part of the UST curve is up about 8 percent and 9 percent, respectively.

Schizophrenic Behavior

This more comprehensive review is more consistent with growing uncertainty rather than trumpeting “record highs.” Because of that, attention will focus, once emotion subsides, toward valuations and the real economic climate that will ultimately determine them.

Even if you don’t think there is any recession danger, any realistic assessment of the current economy does not support either central banks suddenly getting it right nor high earnings multiples (regardless of where interest and discount rates lie).

This more schizophrenic behavior is actually fundamentally more consistent with the economy as it is, casting off if in only discrete periods (of monetary “tightness”) the once-immutable faith in the economy that “will be.” In other words, these more wild swings between hope and despair are what actually matters – indicating the “market” wrestling with its own disappointment as if in one or other of the five stages of grieving.
Old habits, and myths, die hard, so in some ways you can’t blame investors or the media for trying to recreate the “fun” and thrill of 2013 and the days before global QE was so thoroughly disproven.

The reality of the “rising dollar” and the big risk of forward earnings (and the future economy they were supposed to represent) still haven’t been resolved.

At various times over the past two years, stock prices have continued to intermittently shift toward believing again but that was and is nothing like what it once meant. Though the S&P did hit a new record high, it is still fair to conclude that overall stocks really aren’t buying it.

Jeff Snider is head of global investment research for Alhambra Investment Partners. To read more of his work, CLICK HERE NOW.

© 2021 Newsmax Finance. All rights reserved.

1Like our page
All it takes are the words "record high" and all economic or financial sins are forgiven and forgotten.
stocks, market, high, breadth
Friday, 15 July 2016 06:15 AM
Newsmax Media, Inc.
Newsmax TV Live

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved