Tags: Voting | Bush | Tax | Cuts | Divides | Democrats

Voting on Bush Tax Cuts Divides Democrats Before Election Day

Wednesday, 29 September 2010 08:20 AM

Democrats worried about defending congressional majorities are divided over voting on income taxes before Election Day. Party strategists warn they are missing an opportunity to define themselves against Republicans.

After Senate Democrats postponed action on President Barack Obama’s proposal to extend middle-class tax cuts until after the Nov. 2 election, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi suggested members still may vote this week before leaving Washington to campaign. Two days later, House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said that would be a “specious act” without the chance of a Senate vote.

Many Democrats are nervous about a tax vote becoming a campaign issue. Still, Democratic consultants such as Bill Carrick say the party is missing an opportunity to draw a clear line between the parties, with Republicans holding out for tax relief for higher-income Americans and most Democrats siding with keeping the tax cuts only for the middle-class.

“A lot of folks are worried, particularly Democrats in swing districts, that somebody is going to say they voted to raise taxes” if they don’t support cuts for all income levels, Carrick said. “The blunt instrument of a 30-second campaign spot makes people get scared” of Republican attack ads, he said.

Income-tax cuts enacted under former President George W. Bush are set to expire Dec. 31. Obama and most Democrats favor extending them for individuals earning up to $200,000 a year and couples earning up to $250,000 and allowing reductions for higher-income Americans to lapse. They say the U.S. can’t afford tax cuts for top earners amid record budget deficits.

Job Creation

Republicans and some Democrats want to extend the tax cuts for all income levels, arguing that letting taxes go up for the top earners would hurt job-creation. At least five Senate Democrats and all 41 of the chamber’s Republicans say lower rates should be extended across-the-board. In the House, 31 Democrats have spoken in favor of keeping all the tax cuts, the position the Republican leadership takes.

Pelosi favors a vote this week on extending the middle- class cuts to sharpen the contrast between Democrats and Republicans, said leadership aides who spoke on condition of anonymity. Her supporters say it would give Democrats a chance to draw distinctions with Republicans not just on taxation but also on which party would do more to cut the deficit and which party supports the most well-off people.

Individual Democratic views on whether to vote on taxes before the election “depends on what state or district you happen to be from,” said Indiana Senator Evan Bayh, a Democrat who decided not to seek re-election this year.

‘Very Liberal Districts’

“There are some people who come from very liberal districts who want to send a message that they’re not for extending tax cuts, particularly for people who have been successful,” Bayh said in an interview. “Then there’s some others who come from more conservative places” who want “to extend the tax cuts.”

Carrick said Pelosi’s strategy possibly “changes the dynamics” for Democrats by forcing Republicans to choose between extending only middle-class tax cuts and insisting on tax relief also for the most well-off Americans.

“It’s better to do something edgy and take a little risk and try to avert getting really clocked” in the election, Carrick said.

Failure to vote on tax cuts this week would be a “missed opportunity” for Democrats, pollster John Anzalone said in a telephone interview. “The reality is that voters want to see whose side you’re on, and this does it.”

Discipline in Messaging

In a Sept. 15 memo to fellow Democrats, Anzalone cited a CBS-New York Times poll showing that 53 percent of voters favor letting the tax cuts for the wealthiest 2 percent of Americans expire. He cautioned that Democrats “must be exceedingly disciplined in their messaging” on the issue.

Party members were already disagreeing over tax cuts when Anzalone sent his memo. Thirty-one House Democrats led by Jim Matheson of Utah, Melissa Bean of Illinois and Glenn Nye of Virginia, who faces a close re-election fight, said in a Sept. 15 letter to Pelosi that raising “any taxes right now could negatively impact economic growth.”

They urged a one-year extension of all the Bush-era tax cuts.

In a letter this week, 47 House Democrats led by John Adler of New Jersey, also in a tough re-election contest, opposed Obama’s proposal to raise the 15 percent tax rate on dividends and most capital gains for high-income Americans when the rate expires Dec. 31.

Asked yesterday about the internal debate, Hoyer told reporters that Pelosi and all Democrats “are in absolute agreement” that there will be no tax increase on the first $200,000 of all individuals’ income and none “on the first $250,000 of every American family’s income, period.”

‘Held Hostage’

“That objective is being held hostage in the Senate” by Republicans, Hoyer said. “If we thought we could get it through the Senate, absolutely we would act and we might well act anyway” before Congress leaves Washington this week.

Senator Jay Rockefeller, a West Virginia Democrat, said it makes little difference whether Congress votes now or after the election.

“I am not sure that people would even know whether we did or didn’t” vote to extend tax cuts because it would be drowned out in the heat of the campaign, Rockefeller said.

Political science professor Alan Abramowitz of Emory University in Atlanta said a pre-election vote on tax cuts “might make a marginal difference and help a few endangered Democrats.”

Still, he said “nothing is going to make a big difference” because “the mood of the electorate is pretty negative” about the economy.

© Copyright 2018 Bloomberg News. All rights reserved.

1Like our page
Democrats worried about defending congressional majorities are divided over voting on income taxes before Election Day. Party strategists warn they are missing an opportunity to define themselves against Republicans.After Senate Democrats postponed action on President...
Wednesday, 29 September 2010 08:20 AM
Newsmax Media, Inc.

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved