Wall Street’s biggest banks are scouring U.S. data for signals of an impending recession. On balance, they’ve been finding that a 2019 downturn still isn’t likely -- though it’s becoming slightly more so.
The current expansion is eight months away from becoming the longest in postwar history. Most indicators remain solid enough to suggest it’ll get there. But the sell-off in stocks and an inversion in part of the bond yield curve has analysts parsing the tea leaves for anything that points to a contraction in 2019.
Economists at JPMorgan Chase & Co, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Bank of America Corp. are among those who’ve joined the hunt in their recent research notes. JPMorgan sees a 35 percent chance of a recession next year, close to the highest probability in the current cycle, and up from 16 percent in March.
But if a downturn is creeping into the realm of possibility, it’s hardly the base-case scenario. The alarm bells that usually ring when a recession is imminent are doing a muted job of signaling one. Several indicators are slowing down, but economic data have yet to fall off a cliff.
Alarm Bell 1: Jobs Data
Initial jobless claims are among the five most relevant indicators of a coming slump, according to Bank of America economists. “In the last seven recessions, the 6-month growth rate of initial claims has, on average, jumped double digits heading into the recession,” they wrote.
Claims are heading slightly higher on a weekly basis of late, data published Thursday confirmed, but they’ve been at extraordinarily low levels and their recent pop has been relatively small.
Friday’s November jobs report also showed that job gains had slowed slightly. Still, unemployment is very low, wage growth is finally above 3 percent, and the participation rate is stable. “We can’t ignore the pickup in claims, but I don’t think it’s a decisive enough shift to conclude that the labor market is slowing in a troubling fashion,” said Michelle Meyer at Bank of America.
Bank of America’s other top recession signals are auto sales, industrial production, the Philadelphia Fed index, and aggregate hours worked. Some of those are weakening, but none are falling off a cliff. Meyer said her team’s market-based recession indicator shows a 20 to 30 percent probability of a 2019 downturn, while their gauge based on economic data puts the chance at less than 10 percent over the next 6 months.
Alarm Bell 2: Business Surveys
Business sentiment gauges have softened recently, and that’s one reason for the increase in JP Morgan’s recession-predicting index, which is “getting close to the highest levels of the expansion so far,” analyst Jesse Edgerton says. The cycle peak came in 2016 when growth and markets wavered.
“The risks are drifting toward the economy being softer,” Edgerton says, though he adds that surveys aren’t uniformly weak, and his team still isn’t predicting a 2019 recession. He’ll be focused on high-frequency data, including the regional Fed business reports, for an up-to-date picture of activity.
Alarm Bell 3: Yield Curve
Much ink has been spilled about the recession-predicting magic of a yield curve inversion -- a situation in which rates on short-dated debt securities move above those on longer-maturity bonds. The closely-monitored gap between 2-year and 10-year yields has been narrowing, and a less fashionable portion of the yield curve has already inverted.
When the yield curve flips, a downturn usually follows. “We hardly have any empirical regularity that’s this regular,” San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly said in a November interview.
That said, Fed officials so far don’t sound overly concerned about the curve. They’re monitoring it, but they aren’t willing to focus on it exclusively so long as real economic data hold up.
There’s a reason for their reticence. Inversions are a “flawed crystal ball,” UBS Global Wealth Management’s Chief Investment Officer Mark Haefele wrote in a Dec. 5 note. While a flip in the 10-year and 2-year curve preceded each of the past seven recessions, the lag was longer than 24 months on the last two occasions.
The Summary Measure
One of the widest measures of what economists expect, the Fed’s Survey of Professional Forecasters, shows that they’re starting to sour on the economy’s prospects four quarters from now. But their pessimism might be too remote to mean much.
The Survey puts the odds that economy will be shrinking in a year’s time at 23 percent. That’s the highest level since 2008 -- but it still implies a recession probability of less than 20 percent, according to a Goldman Sachs analysis based on the Survey’s track record. Forecasts are pretty inaccurate that far out, and respondents put a low probability on a recession within the next couple of quarters.
That “supports our view that a 2019 recession is unlikely,” economists Daan Struyven and David Mericle conclude. The wisdom of crowds can work, they say, “but primarily at relatively short horizons.”
In the end, markets and hard data are sending different signals right now. And most economists are sticking with the latter -- along with survey numbers -- until a more decisive shift becomes obvious.
“The incoming data continues to be good,” Deutsche Bank’s Torsten Slok wrote in a Dec. 6 note. “Where is this recession the market is so worried about?”
© Copyright 2023 Bloomberg News. All rights reserved.