Tags: Donald Trump | Money | Economy | Sanders

Trump, Sanders Agree: Economy in Ruins

Image: Trump, Sanders Agree: Economy in Ruins
(AP) 

By
Friday, 11 Mar 2016 08:16 AM Current | Bio | Archive

The energy fueling the presidential campaign — on both sides of the political spectrum —seems to be a deep despair about the American economy.

On this central issue, Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump have a surprisingly similar message: The American economy has failed.

But is the analysis correct?

The U.S. economy has created 14 million private-sector jobs since 2010.

Unemployment has dropped to under 5 percent, and the number of people filing jobless claims hit a 42-year low last year.

The Dow Jones industrial average has more than doubled under Barack Obama, among the strongest stock market performances under any president.

Housing and construction markets are strong, auto sales are booming, and even wages have begun to rise.

The central dilemma for the United States is that the gains from growth, low inflation and technological productivity are spread broadly through the entire population. We all gain from lower-cost goods and extraordinary technology.

But the costs — the jobs lost, the wages cut — are concentrated among a smaller group of people. It is the voices of these people, understandably angry, that we hear on the campaign trail these days.

The present recovery has been much less robust than previous ones. But many economists predicted this from the start, pointing out that slowdowns caused by a financial crisis batter the confidence of consumers and businesses.

The most relevant metric surely is how the United States has emerged from the recession compared to the world's other major economies.

And on this the evidence is clear.

The U.S. economy will likely grow much faster than the eurozone's and almost three times as fast as Japan's this year. In the U.S., the Federal Reserve has started to raise interest rates because it worries about growth producing inflation, while almost every other major central bank in the world is thinking of cutting rates to try desperately to jump start the economy.

On the Republican campaign trail, one of the ritual denunciations you hear is that the Obama administration has strangled the economy with new regulations.

The centerpiece of that argument is surely the Dodd-Frank law, a vast, complex, and unwieldy set of regulations that now govern the financial industry.

And yet, as the Financial Times reported this week, America's top five investment banks took in more than twice as much money as their European counterparts, beating "their European rivals on almost every financial measure last year."

Their cumulative pretax profits were $33.5 billion, eight times those of the European banks. "It is the latest illustration of the growing global dominance of the U.S. investment banks," the FT concludes.

The argument that the economy would grow faster if there were major tax and regulatory reforms is certainly a plausible one in theory. But the United States is actually a very competitive economy.

A recent UBS report for the World Economic Forum identified the countries best able to take advantage of the "fourth industrial revolution," and America ranked fifth.

It's certainly true that America has problems, with unwieldy tax and regulatory systems. In rankings released recently by U.S. News and World Report, in the "open for business" category, the U.S. clocks in at a shocking 23rd.

But there is a growing consensus among businessmen and economists that the current circumstances are unusual, almost unique, with people and companies hoarding their savings, wages depressed, inflation nonexistent, and a real danger of deflation.

In an essay in Foreign Affairs, two senior executives at Blackstone, J. Tomilson Hill and Ian Morris, point out that the evidence from Europe is now clear: Those countries that undertook substantial structural reforms, like Greece and Portugal, have not been rewarded with economic growth.

"Pro-market reforms have not corresponded with strong economic recovery," they write.

In the same issue of Foreign Affairs, Lawrence Summers, the former president of Harvard and former U.S. treasury secretary, carefully explains why the fundamental problem in the economy is a lack of demand (too much savings, too little spending) and advocates as the single, central solution a major boost in infrastructure spending.

He has pointed out to me before that, as in a house, deferred maintenance simply ensures you have a much larger bill when things actually break down.

Better to borrow money at historically low rates and spend it now to boost growth and kick-start a virtuous cycle of demand. "Future generations will be better off owing lots of money in long-term bonds at low rates in a currency they can print than they would be inheriting a vast deferred maintenance liability," he writes.

From what they have said repeatedly about infrastructure on the campaign trail, it appears that Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders would agree with much of this.

Could this be the start of a bipartisan pro-growth agenda for America?

Fareed Zakaria hosts CNN's "Fareed Zakaria GPS," and makes regular appearances on shows such as ABC's "This Week" and NBC's "Meet The Press." He has been an editor at large Time magazine since 2010, and spent 10 years overseeing Newsweek's foreign editions. He is a Washington Post (and internationally syndicated) columnist. He is author of: "The Post-American World." For more of Fareed Zakaria's reports, Go Here Now.






 

© Washington Post Writers Group.

   
1Like our page
2Share
FareedZakaria
The energy fueling the presidential campaign seems to be despair about the American economy. On this issue, Sanders and Trump have a similar message. Could this be the start of a bipartisan pro-growth agenda for America?
Economy, Sanders
858
2016-16-11
Friday, 11 Mar 2016 08:16 AM
Newsmax Inc.
 

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

NEWSMAX.COM
America's News Page
© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved