Tags: deal of the century | trump | mideast

Anticipating Trump's 'Deal of the Century'

Anticipating Trump's 'Deal of the Century'
U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to the press prior to departing on Marine One from the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, D.C., April 10, 2019, as he travels to Texas to speak about the economy and attend political events. (Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images)

By
Monday, 15 April 2019 04:16 PM Current | Bio | Archive

President Trump's peace plan for the Palestinian-Israeli conflict surfaced two years ago and to this day — remarkably — only he and a handful of aides know its precise details. A stream of leaks, however, contains enough internal consistency that their collation, supplemented by conversations with administration officials, provides a plausible outline of the plan's contents.

These suggest the plan boils down to a grand exchange: The Arab states recognize Israel and Israel recognizes Palestine, both with capital cities in Jerusalem. This approach builds on elements forwarded by Egypt's President Sisi in 2016, the Obama administration in 2009, the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative, and even my 1990 symmetry plan.

These prior plans either had Israel go first or called for simultaneous steps; in contrast, Trump's has the Arab states initiate, with Israel responding. This change prompted Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority (PA) immediately to reject the "deal of the century" when he met with Trump in May 2017; one report noted that "Abbas has long feared such a plan" and "vehemently opposed" it.

Despite that reaction, the purported deal contains many elements favorable to the Palestinians:

  • Palestine consists of Areas A and B on the West Bank in their entirety and parts of Area C; in all, it will constitute 90 percent of the West Bank;
  • The capital is within or near Jerusalem's expansive municipal boundaries, perhaps in an area stretching from Shuafat to Isawiya, Abu Dis, and Jabal Mukabar;
  • An international body oversees a joint PA-Israeli administration governing Jerusalem's Holy Basin (including the Old City);
  • A joint PA-Jordan body controls Jerusalem's Islamic sanctuaries;
  • Egypt, Jordan, and Lebanon give more rights to their Palestinian residents;
  • Jewish residents in smaller West Bank towns are relocated;
  • A land passage connects the West Bank and Gaza;
  • Gaza joins Palestine when the PA regains control of it;
  • Washington organizes a gigantic economic aid package (perhaps $40 billion, or roughly $25,000 per Palestinian resident of the West Bank) for the PA;
  • Palestinians enjoy temporary access to select Israeli seaports and airports until foreign funds build exclusive PA facilities.

In exchange, the Palestinians apparently will be asked to accept several limitations:

  • Continued Israeli military control over Palestine's borders, its air and sea access, and the Jordan Valley;
  • Legal recognition by the U.S. government (and perhaps annexation by Israel) of larger Jewish towns amounting to 10 percent of the West Bank;
  • Giving up the "right of return" for Palestinians living outside Israel in favor of compensation;

Assuming this outline to be correct in the essentials, it raises three main worries. First, the benefits to Israel are illusory. Its peace treaties with Egypt (signed 40 years ago) and Jordan (25 years ago) led not to significant trade, friendly diplomatic relations, or an increase in human contact. Rather, they intensified anti-Zionist sentiments among Egyptians and Jordanians while improving their governments' arsenals. The same pattern of heightened hostility also followed other Arab diplomatic agreements with Israel – Lebanon in 1983, the PLO in 1993; why should Saudi or Bahraini recognition be otherwise? In other words, Arab state recognition hardly benefits Israel and could hurt it.

Ending the Palestinian claim to a "right of return" is Israel's other illusory benefit. Just recall the farcical 1990s non-change of the PLO charter to drop its call for Israel's destruction to anticipate the hollow theatrics ahead.

Second, despite the Palestinians gaining real and irreversible benefits (money, territory, legitimacy), they with certainty will continue their century-old pattern of rejecting Israel through campaigns of delegitimization and violence, as has been the case since the first Palestinian-Israeli agreement in 1993. That's because Shimon Peres' discredited "New Middle East" idea, that enriching and rewarding Palestinians makes them peaceable, underlies the reported Trump plan. Long experience, however, shows that these benefits makes them more inclined to eliminate the Jewish state. In brief, the PA will pocket "Palestine" and intensify its anti-Zionism.

Third, should Israelis complain to Trump about that delegitimization and violence, he will likely respond with annoyance: The Palestinian-Israeli conflict is now "off the table" and they should move on. Should they persist, his predictable rage will damage not just Israel but also the anti-Tehran campaign and anti-Islamist efforts in general.

In short, the reported plan repeats the great miscalculation of traditional Palestinian-Israeli diplomacy by asking too little of Arabs and too much of Israelis. I predict that it will fail, just as did those of Clinton, George W. Bush, and Obama.

Therefore, Americans concerned about Israel, Iran, and Islamism need to prepare for the imminent unveiling of what could be a problematic plan. Yes, so far, Trump has been "the most pro-Israel president ever" but, as the Bible reminds us, "put not your trust in princes."

Daniel Pipes, a historian, is president of the Middle East Forum. He has served in five presidential administrations and has taught at Harvard, Chicago, and other leading universities. Mr. Pipes is the author of 16 books on the MidEast, Islamism, and other political topics. His latest is "Nothing Abides." He writes a regular column and is a frequent TV and radio guest. Please visit danielpipes.org for an archive of his writing and to sign up for his e-mails. For more reports from Daniel Pipes — Go Here Now.

© 2019 Newsmax. All rights reserved.

   
1Like our page
2Share
DanielPipes
President Trump's peace plan for the Palestinian-Israeli conflict surfaced two years ago and to this day — remarkably — only he and a handful of aides know its precise details.
deal of the century, trump, mideast
871
2019-16-15
Monday, 15 April 2019 04:16 PM
Newsmax Media, Inc.
 

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

NEWSMAX.COM
America's News Page
© Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved