Wall Street’s biggest bond traders are stockpiling Treasurys at the fastest pace since 2007 on speculation the Federal Reserve will announce a plan this week to buy longer-term debt to spur the faltering economy.
The 20 primary dealers held $15.1 billion of Treasury securities due in more than one year as of Sept. 7, up from a $75 billion bet against the debt on May 6, Fed data show. The last time dealers bought bonds at such a rapid pace was between July 2007 and September 2007, as losses on subprime mortgages began to infect credit markets and the central bank unexpectedly cut interest rates.
All but one firm expects the central bank to announce some type of what traders call Operation Twist, according to a Bloomberg News survey, the latest step by the Fed in its four- year effort to keep the economy out of a recession. U.S. debt due in 10 years or more has returned 17 percent this quarter, the most since the last three months of 2008, as unemployment holds above 9 percent and growth slows.
“The problems are endless” for the economy, William O’Donnell, the head U.S. government bond strategist in Stamford, Connecticut at RBS Securities Inc., a primary dealer, said in a Sept. 13 telephone interview. “What will surprise people is how long this period lasts of very, very low rates.”
Treasury 10-year note yields fell to a record 1.877 percent on Sept. 12, before ending the week at 2.05 percent. That’s down from this year’s high of 3.77 percent on Feb. 9. The benchmark 2.125 percent security due August 2021 fell 1 5/32, or $11.56 per $1,000 face amount, to 100 21/32 in the five days ended Sept. 16, Bloomberg Bond Trader prices show.
Treasurys were closed in Japan today for a holiday, and trading is scheduled to take place as usual in London and New York.
Yields fell as evidence mounted that the economy wasn’t responding after the Fed, led by Chairman Ben S. Bernanke, cut its target interest rate for overnight loans between banks to almost zero and purchased $2.3 trillion of bonds from November 2008 through June to drive down market borrowing costs.
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development cut its forecast for U.S. gross domestic product on Sept. 8 to 1.1 percent this quarter and 0.4 percent in the fourth. That’s down from the prior estimate of 2.9 percent and 3 percent.
“The market is pricing in a reasonable probability of the Fed not being able to stimulate growth in any meaningful way,” Shyam Rajan, an interest-rate strategist in New York at Bank of America Corp., a primary dealer, said in a Sept. 12 telephone interview. “On the margin every step helps. But is this a cure- all for the economy, doing Operation Twist? No.”
Operation Twist gets its name from a policy conducted by the Fed in cooperation with the Treasury Department in 1961, when the central bank bought long-term securities as the government concentrated its issuance in shorter maturity debt.
While Fed staff called it Operation Nudge, it became known as Operation Twist, after Chubby Checker’s hit, The Twist, according to a report published March 14 by Eric Swanson, an economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. The move lowered long-term Treasury yields by about 15 basis points, or 0.15 percentage point, according to Swanson.
Policy makers meet the next two days, after Bernanke said in an address at the Kansas City Fed’s annual monetary policy conference Aug. 26 that the Fed still had “a range of tools that could be used to provide additional monetary stimulus.”
Minutes of the Fed’s Aug. 9 meeting released Aug. 30 showed that some central bankers said selling debt with shorter maturities and purchasing longer-term securities had the potential to push borrowing costs lower.
The Fed holds $1.66 trillion of Treasurys, including $520 billion of debt due in 2014 and sooner that could be sold and reinvested in securities maturing from 2018 to 2039, according to CRT Capital Group LLC strategists David Ader and Ian Lyngen. That may pull 10-year yields down to 1.6 percent, they said.
Economists and strategists at Credit Suisse Group AG, another primary dealer, said in a Sept. 16 report that the Fed will likely announce that it’s buying $400 billion of Treasurys with maturities of seven to 10 years over the next six months.
Any signs that Europe is moving closer to resolving its debt crisis may keep bonds from rallying. Yields may rise to 2.5 percent for 10-year notes and to 3.75 for 30-year bonds by year- end if officials from the 17 nations that share the euro are able to insulate the region’s banks from Greece, Ireland and Portugal, said Amitabh Arora, an interest-rate strategist in New York at Citigroup Global Markets, another primary dealer.
German 10-year bunds yielded 1.86 percent on Sept. 16, compared with 21.2 percent for similar maturity Greek securities.
The effect of an Operation Twist is “pretty much priced in,” Arora said in a Sept. 13 telephone interview. “What’s not priced in is a change in outlook for growth. As long as the European crisis does not end up a core banking crisis, we’re going to end up higher with yields by the end of the year.”
Cantor Fitzgerald LP is the only dealer surveyed by Bloomberg News to say it doesn’t expect the Fed to announce an Operation Twist-like policy.
“There’s a concern about the marginal impact of operations like this,” Brian Edmonds, the head of interest rates at Cantor in New York, said in a Sept. 16 telephone interview. “We have a low-rate environment. Will another 20 basis points in 10-year notes make a big difference? It might seem like not a great time for the Fed to try something where there might not marginally be a big difference in what they do.”
At least one dealer said there’s a chance that the Fed may go beyond Operation Twist and print more cash to buy $600 billion to $1 trillion of Treasurys if policy makers determine the economy may be heading toward another recession.
“To beat around the bush at this point doesn’t make any sense,” George Goncalves, the head of interest-rate strategy in New York at Nomura Holdings Inc., said in a Sept. 14 telephone interview. “If things are that bad and require easing, I think it’s more effective to go to reserve creation instead of trying to change the composition of the portfolio, which might not necessarily work.”
By focusing on lowering long-term bond yields, policy makers are trying to support demand for homes and cars, as well as for corporate debt, as lawmakers reign in expenditures.
The extra yield investors demand to own U.S. high-grade bonds rather than government debt has widened 12 basis points to 233 basis points this month through Sept. 15, compared with an expansion of 31 basis points to 290 for debentures in Europe, Bank of America Merrill Lynch index data show.
The debt limit extension signed by President Barack Obama on Aug. 2 requires $2.4 trillion in spending cuts over the next 10 years. The economy didn’t add any jobs in August, and the unemployment rate held at 9.1 percent, the Labor Department said Sept. 2.
The ability of monetary policy to boost the economy “is largely played out at this stage,” Michael Cloherty, head of U.S. interest rate strategy at New York RBC Capital Markets, said in a telephone interview Sept. 13. RBC is a primary dealer.
Since the signs of stress in the financial system first began in June 2007, there have been four instances where bond dealers increased holdings of Treasury notes and bonds.
The first and fastest move was from July 2007 through September 2007, when dealers added $98.8 billion as two hedge funds run by Bear Stearns Cos. began to collapse and Paris-based BNP Paribas SA halted withdrawals from three of its funds because the bank couldn’t “fairly” value their holdings.
The Fed addressed that crisis by cutting the discount rate it charges banks for short-term funds by 50 basis points to 5.75 percent in August 2007, followed the next month by reducing the federal funds rate by the same amount to 4.75 percent.
Dealers added $103.8 billion from November 2008 to April 2009, as the Fed began to buy $600 billion of mortgage and related debt. That program was expanded in March 2009 to total $1.25 trillion of mortgages, $300 billion of Treasurys and $200 billion of agency debentures.
The third time came when they increased holdings of U.S. government notes and bonds by $47.5 billion from September 2010 through November 2010, amid rising speculation that the Fed would resume buying Treasurys as growth slowed.
“Certainly, something’s coming from the Fed,” Suvrat Prakash, an interest-rate strategist in New York at BNP, another primary dealer, said in a Sept. 12 telephone interview.
© Copyright 2017 Bloomberg News. All rights reserved.