Obama Under Fire as ‘Day of Rage’ Dawns in Egypt

Friday, 28 Jan 2011 08:55 AM

By David A. Patten

Share:
  Comment  |
   Contact Us  |
  Print  
|  A   A  
  Copy Shortlink
Egyptian security forces are using tear gas, water cannon, rubber bullets, and bamboo canes to attack the tens of thousands of angry anti-government protesters who took to the streets Friday calling for a “day of rage” against Hosni Mubarak’s regime, prompting officials to knock the nation’s global Internet and telephone connections offline in a bid to disrupt the social media the rebels are using to coordinate their efforts.

Hosni, Mubarak, Egypt, day, of, rage
Hosni Mubarak
Sources reported Friday morning that about 85 percent of Egypt’s Internet was offline because Egyptian authorities deactivated it. The only remaining link to the world reportedly is a small Internet service provider that the nation’s banks and equity markets use to link to the rest of the world.

CNN and German news crews report that government security forces have seized or destroyed camera equipment, adding to concerns that Egypt is “going dark.”

“They’re using violence everywhere to put the protesters down,” reported CNN correspondent Ben Wedeman in Cairo, who said most of the demonstrators are remaining peaceful, chanting, waving signs, and marching through the streets.

Marauding crowds of tens of thousands gathered in Cairo to call for a new government. Some threw rocks at police, who fired back with tear gas and rubber bullets.

In recent days, authorities have reported at least seven deaths, 100 injuries, and 1,000 arrests. At one point Friday, the crowds reportedly approached the Mubarak residence.

Concerns are growing that the extremist Muslin Brotherhood, which has thrown its support behind the demonstrations, may use the unrest to seize control of the country.

National hero and Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohamed ElBaradei is in Cairo and told the Guardian newspaper that he believes the Mubarak government is “on its last legs.”

Other demonstrations sprang up around the country. Apparently they were inspired by Tunisia’s Jasmine Revolution. Some observers are speculating that Morocco, Algeria, and Jordan could be the next countries hit by the wave of protests against the strong-arm governments in the Middle East.

ElBaradei himself was caught up in the turmoil Friday. After noon prayers ElBaradei and his supporters joined the protesters, only to face baton-wielding police and water cannons.

The Associated Press reports that “a soaking wet ElBaradei” was trapped inside a mosque for nearly an hour after a water cannon blasted him. ElBaradei’s supporters surround him to provide protection. The AP reports that police “laid siege” to the mosque, and fired tear gas canisters at cars outside the mosque, setting them ablaze.

The turmoil in Middle East also is generating chaos in Washington, where foreign policy experts in and out of the Obama administration are trying determine how America should respond.

The New York Times reported Friday that an analysis of WikiLeaks cables shows that U.S.-Egypt relations warmed up after President Barack Obama took office because he backed off of the Bush administration’s push for spreading democracy and human rights in the Middle East. While the Obama administration continued to push Mubarak to make reforms behind the scenes, it toned down the public pressure regarding human rights. One cable, for example, told a visiting Gen. David H. Petraeus that the United States was seeking to avoid “the public confrontations that had become routine over the past several years.”

Now, there are indications the administration’s effort to play global politics to its advantage by soft-pedaling Egypt's abuses could be backfiring. The Times story notes: “This balancing of private pressure with strong public support for Mr. Mubarak has become increasingly tenuous in recent days.”

Increasingly, the administration is coming under criticism for first appearing to encourage pro-democracy movements that it now seems very reticent to embrace. The clash over human rights also appears to be on the verge of triggering a political clash in the United States: Republicans well remember the tepid White House response to the crackdown on protesters following fraudulent elections in Iran in 2009. Republicans complained that President Barack Obama’s response was too timid.

The administration’s ambivalence stems from the region’s volatility. There is uncertainty over whether stable, Democratic regimes can prevail over the Islamic extremism that is so common in the nations now experiencing unrest.

Obama weighed in on the uprising in Egypt during a YouTube interview on Thursday. Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, who has dominated the country for more than three decades, has been very helpful to the United States, Obama said.

“My main hope right now is that violence is not the answer in solving these problems in Egypt. So the government has to be careful about not resorting to violence, and the people on the streets have to be careful about not resorting to violence. And I think it is very important that people have mechanisms in order to express legitimate differences.”

White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said the administration believes the Mubarak government is stable, and called Mubarak a “close and important partner.”

As part of the administration’s ongoing balancing act, Gibbs added: “We consistently have advocated for the universal rights of assembly, of free speech, of political reform.”

Egypt is hovering on the precipice of a political upheaval, with massive demonstrations set for Friday. Egypt’s Mohamed ElBaradei, a national hero for his high-profile work as head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, has thrown his support behind the rebellion and is calling for a new government.

ElBaradei announced that he will return to Cairo to participate in the huge rally. Egyptian officials have denied reports that Mubarak’s family has fled the country for refuge in London.

Foreign policy experts fear the extremist Muslim Brotherhood may take advantage of the crisis and seize power. The unrest in Egypt is just the latest episode of unrest gripping the region.

In recent weeks, the governments of Tunisia, rocked by the Jasmine Revolution, and Lebanon have fallen. Lebanon now appears to be in the hands of the terrorist organization Hezbollah after a controversial report on a political assassination disrupted the government.

Embarrassing WikiLeaks cables that exposed the corruption of the Ben Ali regime and his family in Tunisia may have contributed to the uprising that deposed that nation’s former president. Observers say the disclosures contributed to the anger that fueled the uprising, which thus far does not appear to be linked to radical extremism.

In a domino effect of Middle East unrest, the Jasmine Revolution inspired mass protests in al-Qaida hotbed Yemen, and in Israel’s neighbor to the south, Egypt.

In Egypt, tens of thousands of protesters have taken to the streets of Cairo and other cities, chanting, waving signs and lobbing Molotov cocktails at police.

Mubarak has responded with the clenched fist that has helped him maintain power for three decades.

On Tuesday, Mubarak outlawed further public demonstrations. That did not discourage the would-be revolutionaries from taking to the streets again in a country stricken by rampant poverty – 40 percent of its workers earn less than $2 per day.

Police reacted with a brutal crackdown, firing tear gas and rubber bullets into the crowd, pummeling protesters with repeated blows from bamboo-cane poles and dragging dissidents away from the safety of the angry crowd.

In the clashes, a government building was torched and six were killed. At least 55 protesters and 15 police were injured, according to various reports. More than 850 protesters have been arrested, Egyptian authorities said.

In the past, Obama appeared to stand firmly with pro-democracy forces. He stated unequivocally in his much-noted June 2009 Cairo speech: “No system of government can or should be imposed by one nation on any other . . . But I do have an unyielding belief that all people yearn for certain things: the ability to speak your mind and have a say in how you are governed; confidence in the rule of law and the equal administration of justice; government that is transparent and doesn't steal from the people; the freedom to live as you choose.

“These are not just American ideas; they are human rights. And that is why we will support them everywhere,” he said.

Similarly, in a recent speech in Doha, Qatar, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton warned that regimes in the Middle East were in danger of “sinking into the sand” if they didn’t enact reforms.

"Those who cling to the status quo may be able to hold back the full impact of their countries' problems for a little while, but not forever," she said, a warning which seems prescient in the wake of Tunisian events.

"If leaders don't offer a positive vision and give young people meaningful ways to contribute, others will fill the vacuum,” she said.

But in recent days, the administration has moved carefully, balancing its support for the right to civil protest with support for Middle East stability. And that equivocation has angered activists, including most notably in Egypt.

ElBaradei, whose work at the IAEA to stop nuclear proliferation earned him a Nobel Peace Prize in 2005, said he was stunned when Clinton released a statement Tuesday describing the Egyptian government as “stable.” She urged restraint and said the Mubarak government was “looking for ways to respond to the legitimate needs and interests of the Egyptian people.”

ElBaradei, an oft-mentioned possible alternative to the 82-year-old Mubarak, appeared to view Clinton’s statement as waffling on U.S. support for the popular uprising. Mubarak has angered many Egyptians by appearing to prepare the way for his son to succeed him, thereby establishing a family dynasty.

“’Stability’ is a very pernicious word,” he told The New York Times. “Stability at the expense of 30 years of martial law, rigged elections?"

He added: “If they come later and say, as they did in Tunis, ‘We respect the will of the Tunisian people,’ it will be a little late in the day.”

Brookings Institution foreign policy scholar Robert Kagan told Politico that Obama may be running out of time to get on the right side of history.

“My impression is that the administration has been basically closing its eyes and praying that it all works out, because anything else seems too hard and too risky,” he told Politico.

“They can still swing to right side of this thing, but one thing I have been most struck by in meeting with [U.S. officials] at all levels over the past year is that as of yesterday, they have no plan in any direction” for how to deal with the anti-government movements sweeping through the Middle East,” said Kagan.

When CBS News sent an e-mail to Gibbs asking whether the administration still supports the Mubarak regime, he replied: "This isn't about support or opposition to leaders — it's about the support of universal rights of assembly and expression. We criticize actions that restrict those values."

State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley described Egypt as an ally and friend of the United States.

One irony of the remarkable human rights movements rippling across the Middle East is that some observers are interpreting it as at least a partial vindication for the pro-democracy policies of former President George W. Bush.

In his “What in the World” segment on CNN this week, host Fareed Zakaria remarked that “there are sprouts of democracy breaking out all over” the Middle East, although he acknowledged that progress is halting and volatile.

Zakaria, a Time magazine editor-at-large, says Middle East democratization began with Iraq, which, although still struggling with religious extremism appears to be establishing a functional, democratically elected, multiparty government and free press.

He also notes that Bahrain and Kuwait have “flirted with reforms.” The region is a hotbed for terror attacks targeting the United States. Many blame the prevalence of extremism on longstanding social, economic and political injustices.

“And, of course, George W. Bush set forth to fix the problem with what he called ‘a forward strategy of freedom in the Middle East,’” Zakaria reported.

The former president urged more freedom and democratic governance in the Middle East, noting that democracies were more prosperous and less likely to foment acts of terror.

“Now, if Bush’s vision does come to fruition,” Zakaria said, “will it be because of America’s military pressure, or despite it?

“That’s an interesting debate . . . Democracy comes out of the development of societies, from economic growth, middle-class restlessness and above all the political failures of dictators. It can be helped from abroad. But ultimately it is an organic process when it is successful.

“But give George W. Bush his due,” Zakaria said. “He saw the problem, and he believed that Arabs were not genetically incapable of democracy, and he put America’s moral might behind the great cause of Arab reform.”

On a less optimistic note, however, Zakaria noted the historic pattern in the Middle East is popular uprisings result in dictatorships rather than democracies. It is a pattern he says that dates back to the 1952 overthrow of the Egyptian monarchy by Abdel Nassar, who ruled Egypt with an iron hand until his death in 1970.

© 2014 Newsmax. All rights reserved.

Share:
  Comment  |
   Contact Us  |
  Print  
  Copy Shortlink
Around the Web
Join the Newsmax Community
Please review Community Guidelines before posting a comment.
>> Register to share your comments with the community.
>> Login if you are already a member.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
Email:
Retype Email:
Country
Zip Code:
Privacy: We never share your email.
 
Hot Topics
Follow Newsmax
Like us
on Facebook
Follow us
on Twitter
Add us
on Google Plus
Around the Web
Top Stories
You May Also Like

Islamist Militia Now Guards US Embassy in Libya

Sunday, 31 Aug 2014 17:37 PM

An Islamist-allied militia group in control of Libya's capital now guards the U.S. Embassy and its residential compound, . . .

Mike Rogers: US Can't 'Humanitarian-Aid' Itself Out of Iraq, Syria

Sunday, 31 Aug 2014 10:23 AM

President Barack Obama's inaction so far against ISIS is a strategic decision in itself, and portends trouble in other a . . .

Lawmakers Urge ISIS Action: 'What is Obama Waiting For?'

Sunday, 31 Aug 2014 12:57 PM

Frustrated Lawmakers urged President Obama to launch stronger U.S. action against extremists in Iraq and Syria, with bot . . .

Most Commented

Newsmax, Moneynews, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, NewsmaxWorld, NewsmaxHealth, are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

 
NEWSMAX.COM
America's News Page
©  Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved