Gay Judge Qualified for Gay Issue

Friday, 29 Apr 2011 04:55 PM

By Susan Estrich

  Comment  |
   Contact  |
  Print   |
    A   A  
  Copy Shortlink
Many years ago, the late and great U.S. District Court Judge Constance Baker Motley of the Southern District of New York was assigned to hear a case alleging sex discrimination by one of New York's top law firms.

The plaintiffs were no doubt as pleased by the assignment as the defendants were displeased: Judge Motley had served as one of Thurgood Marshall's top deputies at the NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund, before Marshall was appointed to the Supreme Court and Motley to the federal district court. She was widely known as a strong supporter of women's rights.

This was, no doubt, why the defendants in the case moved to disqualify her, claiming she could not possibly judge fairly the claims of bias raised by female lawyers against male lawyers.

Motley would have none of it. She refused to recuse herself, pointing out that if being female was enough to disqualify her, then being male was enough to disqualify her male colleagues. And since, as she put it, the southern district did not include any "neuter" judges, she was as qualified as anyone to hear the case.

I couldn't help but remember the story when I heard this week that the sponsors of the anti-gay marriage amendment in California were seeking to have Judge Vaughn Walker's ruling thrown out because he is a gay man who has been in a long-term relationship with his partner.

According to the lawyers for Protect Marriage, they refrained from raising the issue of the judge's sexual orientation (one of the least well-kept secrets in Lawyer Land) during the trial, but once the now-retired 67-year-old Republican appointee disclosed that he was in a long-term relationship, this made him "too similar" to the plaintiffs in the case who were seeking to marry.

Protect Marriage general counsel Andy Pugno was quoted as saying: "We deeply regret the necessity of this motion. But if the courts are to require others to follow the law, the courts themselves must do so as well."

According to Pugno, it is not that the judge is gay, but that he is in a stable relationship that should retroactively disqualify him. If the judge were cruising gay bars and picking up young men, that would — presumably — be fine with Pugno. Come on.

If being gay disqualifies you from taking a position on gay marriage, so does being straight. If being in a relationship is disqualifying, then all of the judges in relationships here in California (and by my reckoning, most of them are) should be disqualified. Walker hasn't said a word about wanting to get married, any more than Motley wanted a job at the firm that was being sued.

As Motley might say, there are no judges with no sexual orientation in California and precious few who have not been in, who are in, or who are on their way out of relationships. That means Walker was as qualified — or unqualified — as any judge to decide this case. His decision should stand.

Protect Marriage's efforts to throw it out because of his private life undermine their claims that they are anything other than another anti-gay group.

© Creators Syndicate Inc.

  Comment  |
   Contact  |
  Print   |
  Copy Shortlink
Around the Web
Join the Newsmax Community
Please review Community Guidelines before posting a comment.
>> Register to share your comments with the community.
>> Login if you are already a member.
blog comments powered by Disqus
 
Email:
Country
Zip Code:
Privacy: We never share your email.
 
Follow Newsmax
Like us
on Facebook
Follow us
on Twitter
Add us
on Google Plus
Around the Web
Top Stories
You May Also Like

Manage Your Healthcare With Persistence

Wednesday, 08 Oct 2014 09:06 AM

I've read a lot of stories about how you're supposed to manage your own health care, produce it even, as I've explained  . . .

President's Safety Above Politics

Friday, 03 Oct 2014 16:10 PM

Try this test. Pick up your local paper and tell me: How many of the issues that people in your community are concerned  . . .

Rest in Peace, Mom

Wednesday, 01 Oct 2014 09:28 AM

Today would be my mother's 88th birthday, which is not so old, but my mother seemed very old eight years ago, when she d . . .

Most Commented

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. American. are registered trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc. Newsmax TV, and Newsmax World are trademarks of Newsmax Media, Inc.

 
NEWSMAX.COM
America's News Page
©  Newsmax Media, Inc.
All Rights Reserved